Rationale: With both my portrait and flash fiction, I tried to focus on
expressing how I feel like two different people. Focusing on the portrait, I
used the black and white filter so that only two colors would be present,
connecting to the ‘two different people” idea. Another edit I did was apply some blur to the picture, as to say that who I am as a person is "blurry". I also didn’t show my face in
the picture so that it would reflect how I don’t have one “defined” face, so my
face can just be up for interpretation to the reader as to which “person” it
is. I also took the picture at the gym because when I’m emotional, that’s where
I go to calm myself and release a lot of anger.
Focusing
on the flash fiction, I wrote it in the second-person. I wrote it as if I was a
future version of myself giving advice to a past version of me when I am just
trying to figure out who I am as a person in moments of self-reflection. I also
touched a bit on my past and how it has shaped those two personalities, but I
didn’t make it more of a focus because I thought it would take away from the
main focus, that being the two personalities.
One-Pager: What causes your personality to be
the way that it is, and is your personality “set in stone” or does it change?
When it comes to these difficult questions, most people believe that over the
course of your life your personality doesn’t change. They also believe that a
large part of your personality is shaped by your parents, that you receive a
lot of their traits. Personally, I believe our personalities are always
changing, based on our life situations, and our surroundings. Essentially, I
believe that our identities are shaped by our experiences in the past.
After listening to a podcast in
class, my belief was only strengthened. In a radio podcast titled, “The
Personality Myth”, Alex Spiegel challenges the notion that our personalities
don’t change. One of her main points, involves an inmate in prison: “One of the
first prisoners she met was a man named Dan. He had the word "hatred"
tattooed on the back of his neck. But as soon as she started talking to Dan,
Cohen completely forgot about the tattoo. His personality didn't seem to have
anything to do with hatred.” She included this story to show that over time,
peoples identities can change, even people who have done horrible things in the
past can re-shape themselves. Another argument that was key to persuading me,
included a statement from a psychologist Lee Ross: “The point, Ross says, is
that ultimately it's the situation, not the person, that determines
things.”People are predictable, that's true," he says. "But they're
predictable because we see them in situations where their behavior is
constrained by that situation and the roles they're occupying and the
relationships they have with us.” I think the fact that an esteemed
psychologist agrees with her argument, really strengthened it as a whole and
sold me on this idea that personalities are ever-changing.
I used to believe, like most people
now, that my personality and identity was “set in stone” and that it would be
that way my entire life. But now that I have grown and experienced more and
more things, I have looked in the mirror, so to speak, and realized that I have
had many different identities. If things are tense at home with my family, I’m
more than likely to be on-edge and emotional. But if my household is
drama-free, (an unlikely scenario) then I’m more than likely going to be
friendly and more laid-back and carefree, it all just depends on the situation.
So after self-reflection, I have realized that the notion that our identity is
just one defined thing that will never change, is something I don’t believe at
all, because it doesn’t apply to anyone that I know, and most importantly, it
doesn’t apply to me.
I can personally relate to this entire blog post. I love the meaning behind your photo and the flash fiction was perfection. Over all great job!
ReplyDeleteYour flash fiction, portrait, and rationale all go great together to get your point across. I liked the way you incorporated your own thoughts in a few of the points you had in your they say and he/she says. The points you bring up in your I say are extremely relate-able, at least to me. I also liked how you showed the two "people" that you said you feel like. It shows that not everyone is able to know who they are or what they're like at any given time. It also shows how other people would only be able to know why you are who you are if they knew the situations you have been in since the last time they have seen or talked to you.
ReplyDeleteMaking the title "Who Are You" was a good idea. It makes the reader question themselves before the even start to read. Overall the entire paper is really great, especially the one pager.
ReplyDeleteHi ~ I'm a teacher-visitor to the class and Ms. Becker invited me to read stories; I'm appreciative of reading yours. This piece of writing resonates with me, it stands out, because you say that after some self-reflection, you "realized that the notion that our identity is just one defined thing that will never change, is something I don’t believe at all, because it doesn’t apply to anyone that I know, and most importantly, it doesn’t apply to me." That is fantastic. Identity IS fluid and changeable! I'm impressed that you're able to get to this point in your life while you are in high school, being bold to embrace this perspective and able to let go of anybody's way of thinking of you (or thinking about yourself in ways) that might constrain and limit who you are or who you want to be. Good for you. Thank you for sharing your story. - Dr. Haynes-Moore (aka visitor to Becker's class)
ReplyDeleteI really like this piece. I can really relate to this piece. I like how in the end you put they come together in the end and make one good person. The black and white really makes the picture.
ReplyDeleteYour title "who are you?' is what made me want to read your piece. Im sorry you have to go through the emotional pain of an unhappy household, thats always very rough. I do think talking about that is really what made your writing powerful though. You were able to talk about how you have multiple faces and you are still trying to figure out who you are. This really makes the reader feel whats going on and makes them connect to the piece its self. You did a great job!
ReplyDeleteYour flash fiction is so nice and I really enjoyed reading it. I think it can apply to almost everyone in different ways which is a really unique way to go about this. I like the optimism you bring, how even though life isn't always easy it makes you a better person.
ReplyDeleteI think it's good you were able to express this and I like this piece because I think lots of people can relate to this.
ReplyDelete